As noted by many, many people, this is one of the weirdest books in the entire series - and that's saying a lot. It's an idea with a lot of potential, possibly too much to fit into a relatively short length of a YA novel, no matter how dark it gets

So how do you think KA handled it? Did she do well, or was this beyond what she was capable of, either due to length restrictions, age restrictions, or her own capabilities?

(This was also the last book KA wrote herself, no ghostwriters, until that final stretch at the end)

What do you think about the other kids handling the two Rachels? How do you feel about the way the division of the "Rachel personality" was handled between the two?

We'll be back later with a full series discussion plurk!

That line is my favourite!

Possibly in the whole series.