I watched the first one but I haven't seen the others

it good?

I'm enjoying it and I have no clue who most of these people are

I've enjoyed it a lot if for no other reason than it's totally solvable and theorizable

Nice

are you doing the voting stuff for potential prizes?4

even though I totes think Megan's wrong on this one, but we've been civil and we both agree on the killer at least

nah, I don't have an account and am not that invested in RT

you should watch the other episodes so I can bombard you with theories :v

I'm a RT sponsor

And I totes think Ben's wrong in combo but have a feeling he's right BUT DAMN I HOPE HE'S WRONG.

I will do it now

who do you guys think is the killer?

do you want spoilers for the released episodes?

no just names

Barbara

it's the survivor that we disagree on

I'm obviously missing some things but the killer is wearing Ryans GTA 5 clothes

yup, it's part of my theory

yes, continue posting observations for my amusement

okay I'm caught up

thoughts?

do you have link to the ryhme?

I forgot about miles for a while

he throws my ideas into chaos

so what's your death order/roles?

I'm trying to think of what the one got what they wanted is referencing

I have a theory for them all but I want to let you form your own first

the pun feels like it has to be barb because barb

holds tongue til you're done

Now the problem is there are 4 people left and 2 rhymes

so to me the killer got killed one has 2 people dying in it

my guess is that Lindsay is the survivor

Ryan is the killer

barb dies on pun

and miles got what he wanted

alright, my theory is Ryan is the survivor, Barb is the killer, Miles dies of a pun, and Lindsay got what she wanted

explain

alright, going in reverse, first off they said that two of the three remaining murder implements have been revealed,

Lindsay has been established to desire a cat, Barb knows where to get her one, Lindsay will be killed by the puma

that makes sense actually

Miles dies of a pun. the only way I can explain this is that the puns that run in my blood line say it to be so. one of the implements left is a treadmill. the killer will run him...for Miles

oh my fucking god

Barb is the killer b/c first off she is the only person who hasn't been shown in someone's company during any of the murders (we know there's only one killer and significant off screen time doesn't pass),

secondly she's been shown to know where to find almost all of the murder implements and the bow that kills Chris is found in the prop room Ryan got sealed in. also only she and Miles knew where to find Gus.

so what are you guys in disagreement over

I believe Ryan is the survivor, Megan thinks it'll be Lindsay

well I'm more likely to believe that Ryan is the survivor because that is exactly who everyone who knows AH and RT stuff would expect to be the killer

also they've been playing with that too

I think Ryan b/c he's had the most character focus, has already survived the most karmic death trap, and fulfills the last survivor reqs of being often put in danger, being disadvantaged, and char development

well we'll see when it happens

yup, basically the next episode will prove one of our theories correct

yeah

Actually I'm not sure about the survivor

All I'm certain is that I do not believe it's Ryan, from a narrative standpoint.

it makes sense narratively as well... but with this kind of development, I'm more apt to believe that he will die somehow.

Barbs clearly the killer tho.

I realized that with Gus's death

Gus is the Blossoming Flower guy right

(again, learning names, for aw hile I was calling them "Wifey, Husbando, Beard, Cat Music, Blossoming Flower, Gavin, and everyone else"

BEcause Gavin was the only name I knew

after talking to ben a bit