homework

when you're done reading everyone's favorite eps, EW then ranks the top 40 episodes

also, the bottom 10

My favorite is What Is and What Shall Never Be. Just love that one.

Love any of the eps with Rob Benedict- they're all good.

Also waaay at the top of my list- Mystery Spot.

That is a tough one! I love many for different reasons. My top ones would be Mystery Spot, Changing Channels, What is and What Shall Never Be, Salvation, Dead Man's Blood, In My Time of Dying, Simon Said, All

Hell Breaks Loose 1 and 2, The Kids are Alright, Supernatural Christmas and Lazurus Rising.

So the title card showcase was cool.

Dean being epically not OK about this is hilarious.

I"m with Dean on this one- I could easily do without the Wincest references.

Cute reaction to Sam telling them they really are the Winchesters, though.

They're releasing the songs, right?

AHHHH~!!!!

Chuck!!!!!

Ok that ending gave me chills!

Metalligirl: I am with Dean too. I can not stand the Wincest stories. I have never read one and will never read one. I also am not a fan of fan fic either.

I was so happy to see Chuck!! I mean the ending was perfect, and then they gave us Chuck.

GloamingOrchid: I was so happy with the necklace and was teary eyed and then Chuck! Had me yelling!

GloamingOrchid: Dean's facial expressions were awesome in this episode!

I loved all the little references to past episodes!

And then CHUCK!!!!

Yes! That man can show so many emotions it is crazy!

Loved it when he looked straight at the camera at us!

I have read alot of Fanfic they are great stories I don't read any of the Wincest stories or what ever they are called, and this episode was for the fans.

Okey dokey- Dean's expression when they were singing Wayward Son? So perfect it was painful.

And then seeing Chuck at the end? OMG so perfect!!

So what do you think that means? I pretty much thought the last time we saw him that he was God.

So is it God we were seeing or Chuck? And if it's Chuck- how is he back? And where has he been??

That is my feeling too.

I really hope this isn't a one-off episode for Chuck- I hope they bring him back into the storyline. That would be great.

I would love that.

Loved this episode! I laughed pretty hard several times, especially when the scarecrow exploded all over the front rows and they just sat there looking shocked for a few seconds, and the wild applause!

I had some reservations about this episode, because I feel like the whole meta thing has been done to death now, but this was really good.

I loved that whole last act. I loved that Dean was able to see a little of their lives through Sam's eyes for a change, and I loved them watching Carry On

Now that song can mean just as much for them as it can for us!

Giving Dean the amulet was perfect. I hope they leave it there (continuity, after all). And then Chuck.

Really all I wanted going into this episode was to see Chuck, and I was so happy they gave us that. I've missed him. I would love to see him back again.

the soundtrack is up on iTunes ($3.99) and there's a free song (Castiel's) on WaterTower Music

I don't do iTunes but told my daughter to get them for me. I especially loved Wayward Son.

My favorite episode will always be Yellow Fever.