I missed out on the Headless Horseman mount in WoW. I tried once a day for the whole event and nuthin'. I know people who got multiples! 
Tanarian
says
Awww. What about a nice hyena instead?
What about a nice hyena instead?
Reghan
says
I didn't get it either. I did, however, get a pumpkin bag! Heh.
I got a pumpkin bag off a random mob!
(A hyena??)
Reghan
says
Me too, when I was getting my Timbermaw rep. *now boasts the title The Diplomat*
Oooooh. I want that one!
Reghan
says
You need to love grinding. 
I never got one but Vort did (lucky bastard)