i don't think we can get magic items, at least

he's certainly got enough items in his inventory back home that he could recover, like the bestiary or john's book

I think you can get magic items, they just won't work

yea

he could get john's mask and then be Distinctly disappointed it doesn't work, haha

(what's john's is his it's the same fucking bag)

he's already got the two items he cares about the most, his lighter and his daughter's music box

arthur is a man of very few possessions

piano? :0

hgsjkld, the image of the boar fucking HORFing up a whole-ass piano

god i still need to think of something

canon items are easy but after playing piano with kate i'm tempted to give him some of his old sheet music so he can regift it to her

Arthur asks the boar for tranquilizers so he can knock himself out and have a fucking break for once

asks for a weighted blanket so he stops vibrating out of his skin

"can you vomit up what I want most: a fuckin break"

djkfhdkfjg funny you should say that because I was thinking of giving Kate a book of sheet music because I can't think of anything to give her tbh

you have the whole of December to make a decision tho! so there's still time!

at arthur's point in canon his worldly possessions are like

the lighter, the music box, the dagger, a couple of eldritch books, a gun, and some random bits and pieces like a cult ring and a shaving kit and stuff

so nothing immediately useful or interesting, hah

and john's mask, which is just the pallid mask

for me, the postcard was the biggest thing I wanted Kate to have. she already has her Bible and her violin so like. I'd honestly need to scour through her room for anything else that's significant to give her

really, it'd probably be a photo of her family?

or her Bunny, Alice. Which would probably be a BAD CALL.

god, i could give arthur a photo of his daughter

ohhh, BIG FEELS TIME

babiest baby

OH NO

that is so darling